Tuesday, October 10, 2006

Stem Cell Research May Have Been Faked

It began with an announcement. Woo Suk Hwang, a scientist from Seoul National University, claimed to have cloned embryonic stem cells from 11 human patients. For those of you who do not know what that means, it was a huge breakthrough towards one day using embryonic stem cells to treat or cure diseases. It could be likened to the discovery of the internal combustion engine in relation to the manufacturing of automobiles. Stem cells could one day be used to help heal spinal cord injuries or cure cancer.

It was enough to earn Hwang a spot in the Scientific American 50 as “Research Leader of the Year”. His work revolutionized the field of therapeutic cloning. “If a time does come when therapeutic cloning becomes the gold standard of care for a variety of diseases, Hwang's innovative and groundbreaking explorations will have paved the way” the Scientific American magazine proclaimed. It was arguably the biggest scientific discovery of the year.

Then along came the ethical concerns. It was revealed that some of the human eggs that were used had come from women who worked in the laboratory with Hwang, leading to the possibility that the donations were coerced. It was then found out that other egg cells had come from paid donors, which is currently not the preferred method of obtainment. Hwang denied the allegations for months in order to, as he said, “Protect the reputations of his co workers”. However, ethical concerns aside, it was still a huge discovery with possibility of future Nobel consideration. South Korean President Roh Moo-hyun even opened a World Stem Cell Hub center, billed as a project to put the country at the forefront of cloning research.

After that came the rumors that the data itself was foul. Several of his published micrographs were wrongly labeled as being different cells when in actuality they were the same cell from a different angle. Hwang claimed it to be a publishing error, but that led researchers to question why the cells were so similar and lacked any experimentally induced variation.

It was shortly after that one of his coauthors, Gerald Schatten of the University of Pittsburgh, asked that his name be retracted from the published paper due to doubts about its accuracy. There were allegations that certain parts of the report were fabricated.

Now, another of the coauthors wants his name to be retracted from the paper. Sung Il Roh, a hospital administrator and specialist in fertility studies who worked directly with Hwang, told a South Korean Television network “Professor Hwang admitted to fabrication."

Seoul National University plans to investigate these claims. They “will probe doubts raised about (Hwang's) 2005 thesis first and, if the doubts are confirmed, will replicate experiments," according to a statement released by the university.

Hwang and his team have not yet been reached for comment, but are expected to brief the media early tomorrow.

Shoutwire

5 comments:

liuyanqiu918 said...

It Ed Hardy Bags was Ed Hardy SPECIALS such Ed Hardy Belts an Ed Hardy Kids Clothing easy birth Ed Hardy Kids T Shirts Szabo says Ed Hardy Active Wear I Ed Hardy Mens T-Shirt was in Ed Hardy Mens Tops the Ed Hardy Mens Hoodies pains Ed Hardy Mens Jeans of Ed Hardy Swim Trunks labor Tiffany and co Bracelets for Tiffany and co Bangles about Tiffany and co Pendants qwe Tiffany and co Earrings aardtz Tiffany and co Necklaces or five Tiffany and co Rings hoursthen Tiffany and co Cuff Links I pushed Tiffany and co Key Rings once Tiffany and co Sets and he Tiffany Bracelet popped out Tiffany Bangle Read more Tiffany Pendant about the Tiffany Necklace Szabos links of london sweetie

一笑千年 said...

As it can certainly always be reported folks stars zjfgksy benefit from getting into oakley frogskins in the personalized variations. Along with these kinds of patterns are generally individual for the children. As a result, while the idea happens to the part of fans, these kind of oakley frogskins are set up approximately related to the patterns ones. while correctly as being a happening comes about, that is, your fans in the accurate Oakley place on Oakley sunglasses of these accurate variations. In addition, these are on the way to almost never change his or her style throughout getting into oakley jawbone .Your younger looking girls-oriented Oakley sunglasses, by way of example, are generally actually common. These kind of sun glasses could be the effects involving reduction regular along with cool issues jointly. specifically can be additional, your charges involving oakley flak jacket may be affordable. This has confirmed that will plenty of buyers will probably pay for the children. And thus, oakley radar can invest in just about any shade as well as any kind Oakley sunglasses whenever they similar to. Your component can be the belief that fans will certainly adhere to your patterns in the idols, of course getting into Oakley sunglasses.Normally, duplicate Oakley sunglasses may be affordable.

oakley oil rig sunglasses said...

You had more desirable not likely earn the 2 main major frame and additionally liaisons jhuyflpzs Oakley. even though you require the most Cheap Oakley Sunglasses or possibly good looking spectacles, an array of Oakley Frogskins help you start conversations any attitude. And additionally customers so, who would really like to start to be top-quality among the most of the contacts could consider relating to all of these spectacles, when they include all the joyful air flow. Still Oakley Frogskin really are prepared work more significant for legitimate optical outlet stores. You may buy low-priced Oakley Radar for those connects and additionally special Oakley Radar Sunglasses loved one most people additionally.

roger vivier said...

Roger vivier heels cheap sneakers terminal block blown film machine surge protective device ball valve manufacturer shox chaussures.Magasin de chaussures hommes et femmes. En plus des langues europeennes, Roger Vivier magasin de chaussures et d'articles de voyages.Chaussures de Fleurs (Flower Shoes). Posted by Flower Spy on Wednesday vivier shoes ,The mark of Frison's mentor, Roger Vivier, is evident in these.Ces magnifiques escarpins sont signes Roger Vivier. roger vivier heels Dans un style tres 80, ces chaussures a talons tres hauts vzkjvnzk .mixent parfaitement jeu.Roger vivier helps you cathch the fashion style and athletes from around the same high school roger vivier chaussures ,wholesale roger vivier chaussures shoes.Roger vivier online contain, Look-alike Chopard Content Sports activity,the anticipations with a atom with the roger vivier chaussures. Roger Vivier, dont le directeur artistique n'est autre que Bruno Frisoni est une maison ou la tradition tient une place importante. Les chaussures.

qinbincai123 said...

You see: The beauty of a woman is not in the clothes she wears,
the figure that she carries, kirefg88 or the way she combs her hair.
Wholesale New Era Hats
Cheap 59fifty Hats
Cheap New Era Hats
New Era Snapback Hats
New Era Fitted Hats